Whoa, really? I guess this means this game must be mostly based on your dimension's variation.

[Winston was like the one guy who got into it but he kept solving all his puzzles instantly and it was all hell.]

I would be! I've DM'd a few times and this seems similar enough that I think I'd be pretty decent at it. I think I'd try out one of the campaigns already written up before I write anything myself, just so we can all get a good feel for things.